When it comes to cruising, it’s two major players that come to mind for most people: Royal Caribbean and Carnival.
And when you think of these two cruise lines you likely envision their massive ships. However, they compete across private destinations as well. Namely, each has a large flagship destination that’s the gem in their portfolio of private ports.
Carnival offers Celebration Key. Royal Caribbean has Perfect Day CocoCay.
Let’s be honest, if you’re visiting either spot, then you’re in for a great day. Both offer a ton to do, beautiful water, sandy beaches, huge pools, and so much more. But there are also differences that you should know about that make us give the nod over its rival.
We lay it all out below…
Size

If there’s one difference that’s most obvious in cruising over the past couple of decades, it’s that the size of cruise ships has soared. So it shouldn’t be a surprise that private destinations also offer plenty of room.
That’s needed because both cruise lines like to dock multiple ships at once, which means 10,000 passengers or more may be ashore during they day. You need plenty of room for people to spread out.
Celebration Key has access to hundreds of acres of space, but the current build-out covers about 48 acres and it is 1.25 miles around. It also offers a half-mile of oceanfront beach.
In comparison, the island that CocoCay sits on is roughly 2.3 miles around, but the actual passenger space takes up much less than that. By our estimate, the public areas for passengers take up about 57 acres.
So right now, CocoCay is the larger of the private spots. That could change rather soon, however. Carnival has more than 150 acres set for future expansion. In other words, expect Celebration Key to get much larger in the coming years.
Beaches

If you’re going to The Bahamas, then no doubt the top thing on your mind is the beach. In that case, both Celebration Key and CocoCay will fit the bill. Both feature beautiful white sand and water that’s a stunning electric blue.
But there are differences between the two.
Let’s start with Celebration Key. While CocoCay is an actual island, Celebration Key is a carve-out of a larger area. Because of that, the beach is a completely straight section of the coast that’s open to the water. This means if the wind is picked up, then currents and waves can make the ocean a bit rougher than you may like.
CocoCay offers something different. Because it’s an island, there isn’t just one beach but several. And Royal Caribbean has built coves around most of them that help protect the beach. So even when the weather is rougher, the water at the beach is somewhat calmer. As well, they have one inlet (Harbor Bay) that is largely closed off from the open ocean, so it’s always calm. That makes it ideal for small kids or those that simply want the calmest water possible.
Pools

Ocean not your thing? Many people prefer to swim in a pool. In that case both CocoCay and Celebration Key have you covered.
Both feature large pools that are focal points of the day. CocoCay has the Oasis Lagoon, which is a 33,000 square foot pool in the middle of the island. It features all sorts of coves, a swim-up bar, and a gentle-sloping beach entry that’s great for kids.
But Celebration Key has two massive pools (it also dubs them lagoons) that mirror each other right in the center of the destination. These lagoons are 265,000 square feet in area, or about eight times the size of CocoCay’s main pool.
That’s good because it means if you want to swim, you’ll have all sorts of space to spread out, even if there are multiple ships in port on the day you visit.
Food/Dining

Food is always a big part of cruising and that extends to private islands. Having visited both spots, we think the food is somewhat similar in that you’re going to get some “beachy” eats with things like sandwiches, burgers, tacos, and the like. As well, there are spots to eat all over the island.
What the big difference is in how you eat and what you can get.
On Royal Caribbean’s CocoCay, it’s simple. There’s a large buffet and several “Snack Shacks.” When you’re hungry, you go eat. Want a snack? Go grab it. It’s straightforward and simple.
With Celebration Key, it’s not like that. Every passenger gets a meal included on the island. Many (though not all) restaurants have an “Island Eats” menu. With your day you get one meal from this menu. (Some restaurants are an extra cost where Island Eats can get you a discount.)
Want more than your one meal? That’s extra.
Frankly, it’s a bit of a downer to have to limit yourself when you’re on vacation. We’d prefer having a full open buffet.
Things to Do

If you want your day to revolve around the beach and the pool, then you will have your fill at either private destination. Both, of course, are featured prominently.
But neither destination is so “sleepy” as to only have those options as things to do. They are both built to essentially be beach-themed amusement parks. As of now, however, we think CocoCay offers more options.
First, there’s what they both share. When you visit you’ll have the beach and pool. Both also offer more exclusive space for a charge. Celebration Key has the Pearl Cove Beach Club while CocoCay has the Coco Beach Club.
There are sports courts and beach games around both destinations and both also feature splash pads. They both also have market areas where you can shop for souvenirs.
Beyond that, however, we feel CocoCay offers more options of things to do. This is driven most notably by two areas that cost extra to visit, but are pretty popular. First is Hideaway Beach, a separate adults-only spot with its own beach and pool. This is the party spot at CocoCay.
The biggest difference, however, is Thrill Waterpark. Now, Celebration Key does have a couple of waterslides. But CocoCay has an entire waterpark with 14 slides, including one that rises 135 feet. There’s a wave pool, an obstacle pool, raft slides, racing slides, and more. It is an extra charge to visit the spot — and often it’s a high price of $100+ per person.
Kid Appeal

If you are sailing to either one of these spots and you are cruising with kids, then there’s a ton to like. Let’s be clear that either spot is a kids paradise with tons for kids to do. If the kids don’t have a good time at either Celebration Key or CocoCay, that’s their own fault.
Both have the beach, pools, sport courts, splash pads and beach games to play.
If you have older kids, we think that CocoCay is likely going to be a bit more fun as it has more adventurous things to do like Thrill Waterpark with tons of waterslides, a series of ziplines, jet skis, snorkeling, and more. However, these items all cost extra so expect to spend some cash if they want the thrills.
If you have smaller kids, then Celebration Key may win out. They offer two smaller waterslides that have a lower price than full admission to the CocoCay waterpark. They also offer a larger pool area and a big splashpad, making it ideal for those with kids who aren’t up for the more adrenaline-raising options.
Use of Onboard Packages

If you take a cruise, then the chances are you bought a drink package, an internet package or maybe even both.
These are major investments that add hundreds to the cost of your cruise. You want to get your money’s worth. If you’re sailing Royal Caribbean, then there is a big advantage to CocoCay.
First, both Carnival and Royal Caribbean allow you to use your internet package when at their private destinations. So when you’re at the beach you can still stream music, post to socials, or anything else you want to do online.
However, when it comes to drink packages, Carnival’s doesn’t allow you to use the package on Celebration Key. If you’re at CocoCay on Royal Caribbean, that drink package works the exact same as when you’re on the ship.
So Which Is Better? Celebration Key or CocoCay?

There’s a lot to like about both Celebration Key and CocoCay. And frankly, if you’re visiting you’ll find a lot that’s similar. It’s days that revolve around the beach and the water, with a lot happening whether you want to spend the day relaxing or spend it being active.
It’s our opinion that while we’d be happy to visit either spot, at this point we’d give the edge to Royal Caribbean’s CocoCay.
Personally, we enjoy actually being on an island versus a carve-out of a larger shore. There’s simply something special about being on an island that’s dedicated solely to you. The atmosphere feels a bit more intimate despite having nearly 60 acres.
Beyond that, we like how the island’s beaches are generally protected from the open water and there are multiple different spots around the island instead of just one long stretch of beach.
We do give credit to Celebration Key for having a massive pool and it’s nice to be able to find a spot, unlike Oasis Lagoon on CocoCay that can get somewhat crowded.
But to us the real difference is the amount of activities that are available on CocoCay. Yes, you’ll pay extra for these. The ability, however, to jet ski, ride massive waterslides, zipline, party in the adults-only spot or relax in a high-end beach club means there’s something for everyone.
More reading:
- What I Wish I Knew Before Visiting CocoCay (Royal Caribbean’s Private Island)
- What I Wish I Knew Before Visiting Celebration Key (Carnival’s Private Destination)












