Which Cruise Line Should I Sail? The Definitive Guide for 2020

When it comes to selecting the right cruise line for you, it can feel a bit like car shopping.

Say you want a new SUV. You have options from dozens of car makers. You have to narrow the list down by price range, reliability, cost, and more. In short order you can feel overwhelmed and your head spins from all the choices.

While cruise lines aren’t as numerous as car companies, there are still lots to choose from. Passengers new to cruising can easily get overwhelmed by the choices, not sure of what the difference is between them all. Is a cruise on Carnival the same as a cruise on Princess? Is a cruise on Royal Caribbean the same as a cruise on Celebrity?

Carnival ship at sunset

If you’re a first-time cruiser and feeling overwhelmed by which cruise line you should sail, don’t worry — you’re not alone. That’s why we’ve created this guide to give you a better idea of each major cruise line — including who the line is perfect for — so that you can pick the right one for your vacation.

Overview: What to Consider in a Cruise Line

Before we can get into the ins and outs of each cruise line and which one you should sail, we need to cover what factors to consider.

The good news? While you have a lot of choices, overall cruise lines are remarkably similar. In fact, you can expect most aspects of your trip to be the same. Different cruise lines are more like different airlines. There are noticeable differences, but the experiences is largely similar. That means you won’t have to worry about picking the wrong line; the worst “fit” cruise line is still likely to be a lot of fun for you.

That said, there are differences between the lines that can make one perfect for you. In particular, we suggest cruise passengers look at the five following areas:

Atmosphere
What is the atmosphere on a cruise ship? For lack of a better term, this is the “feel” of the ship. Is the vibe like a party? Or is it more refined and elegant? If you don’t wear a tux to dinner will you feel out of place? Or is anything more than flip-flips and shorts considered to be too dressy?

Each cruise line has a different feel that they have onboard. Just like the difference between a casual hotel and a fancy hotel, different atmospheres appeal to different passengers.

Activities
Needless to say, different cruise passengers are interested in different activities. Some folks are happy to just sit poolside, soak up some sun and read a book. Others need a thrill a minute and want to do things like waterslides, play games, and even drive go-karts on a cruise ship. Still others want cultural things to do like learning about ports of call or attending cooking classes.

Passenger Focus
Perhaps the biggest difference between cruise lines has to do with the passenger focus. This relates to what sort of passengers the cruise line caters and markets to. In other words, who will you be sailing with on the ship?

Some cruise lines focus on luxury — aiming to attract older, wealthier passengers. The mass-market cruise lines focus on everyone, from families to Spring Breakers to couples celebrating their 50th anniversary. Obviously with so many people on a ship, who you sail with has a big impact on the right cruise line for you.

Ships
Over the past decade the cruise industry has seen an arms race among ships. The modern cruise ship is completely different than those found just a few years ago. They are larger, more luxurious, and have more amenities by far. And with the cruise ship being one of the most important factors in the enjoyment of your cruise (after all, you spend the majority of your vacation onboard), then a cruise line with a fleet of bigger and newer ships is important.

Price
When it comes down to it, so many people love cruising because it offers a lot of value for the price. Where else can you travel to distant ports, playing hopscotch with tropical beaches and not break the bank? Truth is, however that you can spend as much as you want on a cruise and some lines appeal to those looking to spend a bit more to get more and others appeal to budget-conscious cruisers. Picking the right cruise line for your budget can make a big difference.

Cruise Lines & Which Is Right For You

So which cruise line should you sail? Below we’ve profiled each — including who is most apt to enjoy it — paying special attention to the factors mentioned above.

Carnival
As the largest cruise line, if you’ve searched for a cruise to sail at all then chances are you’ve come across an offering from Carnival. Each year millions of passengers sail the cruise line, known for its highly affordable prices. Some trips sail for as little as a couple of hundred dollars per person. It’s also a popular choice as for-purchase items like drinks, specialty restaurants, Internet and other things are relatively inexpensive compared to rivals.

It’s not just price that makes Carnival so attractive to many passengers. The line offers more homeports than any other, including smaller ports of call like Baltimore, Charleston, and Mobile. That means a cruise is within driving distance for millions more people.

Known as the “Fun Ships,” the vibe on Carnival is always relaxed and never stuffy or formal. If you’re looking for casual, this is it. That relaxed atmosphere along with a low price point means you get a wide range of passengers, ranging from families with kids to college-aged kids and those simply wanting a getaway without spending a fortune.

While the cruise line continues to build out its fleet, many of its current ships are older. As well, Carnival doesn’t have the reputation for having as many high-octane things to do on the ship as its main rival Royal Caribbean. Still, the ships offer lots to do in a classic cruise sense — including tons of bars, restaurants, and pools.

Who Carnival Is Right For: Those wanting to have a good time while not spending a ton of money. With so many ships and ports, the line also makes it easy to find a cruise that fits any schedule. The cruise line has something for all ages and for families, singles, and couples.

Read: 12 Major Differences Between Carnival and Royal Caribbean

Royal Caribbean
While Carnival may be the largest cruise line by passengers carried, Royal Caribbean would be the largest if you went by the size of the ships. Four of the five largest cruise ships in the world are from Royal Caribbean.

Those large ships are much more than just big empty spaces. The cruise line also pushes the envelope for things to do on its ships. It’s Royal Caribbean that offers the tallest slide at sea (The Great Abyss), along with the FlowRider standing waves, Splashaway Bay, NorthStar (an observation pod that goes high above the ship), ice skating rinks, laser tag, any number of bars, restaurants, and pools. In short, Royal Caribbean takes top prize when it comes to its ships and the things to do for the entire family.

The atmosphere on the ship is also enviable. It’s largely relaxed, but with hints of luxury. During the day, shorts and flip-flops are the order, but nights can turn more elegant. The feel is a step above Carnival in luxury, without going overboard.

For all this you’ll pay a higher price. Older ships on Royal Caribbean often have cheap fares, but you will pay a premium to sail on the newer, larger ships.

Royal Caribbean is a mass-market cruise line, which has appeal to everyone. Families with kids will especially like the number of things to do for children but there is something for everyone.

Who Royal Caribbean Is Right For: Those wanting a more luxurious cruise while still keeping the casual atmosphere. Everyone from families to retirees will find something to like on the ship, and the passengers are often more affluent due to the higher price point.

Read: Major Differences Between Royal Caribbean and Norwegian

Norwegian Cruise Lines
Norwegian rounds out the “big three” cruise lines, along with Carnival and Royal Caribbean. These three lines have a firm hold on the majority of the cruise market. And while Norwegian is the smallest of the three, it has a lot to like.

Perhaps most interesting is how the cruise line seems to be catching up to rival Royal Caribbean. In terms of ships, Norwegian’s aren’t as large as its rival but they are steadily increasing and size and more closely compare to Royal Caribbean than Carnival.

As well, the cruise line continues to push the envelope with onboard activities. Its newest ships have noteworthy features like go-kart tracks and extreme waterslides jutting out over the edge of the ship. There are also features like laser tag arenas and virtual reality experiences.

Norwegian — like its main competitors — is a mass-market cruise line. That means it will appeal to all ages and types with lots to do for everyone. Meanwhile, the atmosphere on the ship is also comfortable, with a relaxed vibe that has touches of luxury. The general prices on the ship are higher than its two main competitors, which helps to stem some of the “party” atmosphere you might find elsewhere.

Who Norwegian Is Right For: Norwegian is ideal for those wanting large ships with lots to do, but are willing to pay a higher price than some other lines. Our research found the average amount earned per passenger highest on NCL compared to Royal Caribbean or Norwegian.

Newer ships will have more to do compared to older vessels and are ideal for everyone from families to empty-nesters. Look at the cruise line’s “Haven” suites if you are looking for a more luxurious trip.

Read: Major Differences Between Norwegian and Carnival

Princess cruise ship logo

Princess Cruises
So far we’ve discussed the large cruise lines that try to appeal to everyone. However, not every cruise line aims to do that. Case in point is Princess Cruises. While anyone and everyone is welcome aboard, it definitely aims to appeal to those wanting a more luxurious and relaxing vacation. For instance, not everyone looks for a cruise line that serves afternoon tea like Princess does.

While the ships have plenty to do, they don’t try to go over-the-top with things like go-karts and roller coasters. Instead, the focus is on more enriching activities like stargazing on the top deck of the ship, musical productions, and fine dining.

Everywhere you turn there are smaller touches designed to pamper guests. For example, the ships have the “Princess Luxury Bed” that’s a step above what you’ll find on most cruise ships. There is also free room service, a rarity on most lines.

As for ships, you’ll see smaller vessels than what you’ll get with other cruise lines. The cruise line’s newest ship, for instance, holds about 3,600. Most new cruise ships hold between 5,000-6,000 passengers. What’s interesting is that while there are fewer economies of scale with smaller, ships prices for Princess are not that much higher than the major cruise lines. In other words you can sail in luxury for only a little more.

Who Princess Is Right For: Those who will feel most at home are affluent passengers who enjoy the finer things in life. There are amenities for families, but the cruise line is more popular with older passengers looking for a more refined experience.

Alaskan cruise ship

Celebrity
While Princess is the luxury cruise line owned by Carnival Corporation, Celebrity is the luxury line owned by Royal Caribbean. In many ways you’ll find similarities between Royal Caribbean and Carnival, you’ll also find similar experiences on Princess and Celebrity.

The cruise line has a definite focus on luxury and service, with an atmosphere aimed toward more refined travelers. For instance, while some cruise lines boast about their rock-climbing walls or laser tag, Celebrity mentions famous chefs, a ballet company, and glass-blowing classes on their ships.

And while kids are of course welcome, your other passengers are most likely to be older and more affluent. In other words, kids might be more bored on a Celebrity cruise compared to some of the family-oriented lines.

Celebrity has made a splash with recent new ships. Most notably is the Celebrity Edge, a ship launched last year that has set a new mark in luxury. Its most famous feature is the “Magic Carpet” — a platform on the side of the ship at goes up and down decks providing a one-of-a-kind experience. As well, older ships are undergoing the “Celebrity Revolution” — a $500 million upgrade plan across the fleet to redesign and add new features .

As you would expect, Celebrity charges a premium for its cruises. It’s definitely a “pay more, get more” situation. That said, the prices aren’t that much more than a cruise on a budget-focused line. We found trips to be a few hundred dollars more than what you’ll find with other carriers.

Who Celebrity Is Right For: As with Princess, we think older passengers who want a more refined and relaxing experience will be a fit for Celebrity. If you’re the sort of person who wants to enjoy the spa and sip champagne without lots of noise or kids around, then the cruise line might be for you.

Disney Ship

Disney
If you have kids and are interested in cruising, then you’ve no doubt thought about a Disney cruise. The company known for its theme parks, movies, and resorts is also in the cruising business. And those touches you’d expect from Disney make their way to the ships.

For one, the style of Disney cruise ships is unlike any other cruise line’s vessels. The ships have a distinctive “retro” style (despite being modern vessels) that harken back to the elegance of cruising in the early days.

Of course, you’d expect a Disney cruise to be focused on children and families and it certainly is. Characters like Mickey and Donald Duck roam the ship and there are other experiences with Disney-owned properties like Marvel and Star Wars. While there is plenty for mom and dad to do — such as the spa, adults-only eateries, and nightclubs — we think that only adults who are very into Disney would think of sailing the cruise line without kids.

Notably, we’ve heard mention that drinks are not as free-flowing as you’ll find on most cruise ships and no Disney cruise ships have casinos. In other words, if you want a more “adult” time then you likely want to look for another cruise line.

You might expect given the cost of visiting Disney World it would be pricey to sail on the ship. You’re right. Of all the major cruise lines, we’ve found Disney to be the highest priced. For example, we found four-night cruises in July, which might be $300-400 on most cruise lines selling for about $1,000-1,500 per person on Disney. That’s a high price to pay, but many people rave about the service and experience on a Disney cruise.

Who Disney Is Right For: You guessed it. Disney cruises are ideal for those families wanting to have a vacation that the kids will remember. The price is expensive compared to other cruise lines, so you’ll want to be willing to open up your wallet for the experience.

Have more questions about finding the right cruise line? Let us know in the comments below.

Which Cruise Line Should I Sail? The Definitive Guide for 2020

Popular: 39 Useful Things to Pack (17 You Wouldn't Think Of)

Read Next: Park & Cruise Hotels for Every Port in America

Popular: 107 Best Cruise Tips, Secrets, Tricks, and Freebies

Popular: Risks of Cruising Without Insurance (3 Big Reasons)

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here